The Existential Primer

Forums | About | Tameri
Introduction | Definitions | Ethics | Divisions | Context | Resources | Suggested Reading |
Beauvoir | Heidegger | Jaspers | Kierkegaard | Nietzsche | Sartre |
Camus | Barth, J. | Dostoevsky | Goethe | Kafka |
Introduction | Barth, K. | Buber | Marcel | Niebuhr | Tillich |
Introduction | Frankl | May |
Introduction | Hegel | Husserl | Marx |
Merleau-Ponty | & more… |

Before Existentialism

small logo

Introduction

Before The Existentialists began recording their philosophies, several writers had already explored the absurdity of life and the inherent difficulties of free will. John Milton's Satan in Paradise Lost, Goethe's Mephisto in Faust, and Dostoevsky's collection of troubled anti-heroes are the literary embodiments of free will. Milton's Satan is almost admirable for his unwillingness to serve in Heaven and accepting his resulting role. Faust is an archetype; he is the scientist willing to trade his soul for knowledge of absolute truths. Both of these characters represent the existential ideal: they accept their fates, however absurd, in return for a form of freedom.

These writers suggest some existential ideals, but predate the label. In the case of Dostoevsky, it can be debated whether or not he was among The Existentialists. Regardless, he is the author of the definitive Christian existentialist poem, The Grand Inquisitor. This one poem explains the difficulties of faith and freedom better than Nietzsche or Kierkegaard ever did.

Individuals influential to existentialism:

John Milton

Long before the French Resistance rebels Camus and Sartre became literary and philosophical powers, John Milton was rebelling against his country's government and church. Milton's great works, written during the last decade of his life, highlight a concern with individual choice and responsibility. It should be no surprise that Milton did not believe in the Divine Right of the Crown or in infallibility of the Church of England.

Milton's first work of note was Lycidas, a pastoral elegy written to honor Edward King, a classmate at Cambridge. An elegy is a poem adhering to strict conventions meant to honor a lost friend. King died in 1637 while sailing to Ireland to visit his family. Milton used the opportunity to criticise the church. Milton's dedication introducing the poem indicates his intent:

In this monody the author bewails a learned friend, unfortunately drowned in his passage from Chester on the Irish Seas, 1637. And by occasion foretells the ruin of our corrupted clergy, then in their height.

The poem explores the meaning of existence, the role of the church, and the Creator's role in destiny. Written nearly 30 years before Paradise Lost, the basic themes that would dominate Milton's works are apparent.

Milton considered the individual more important than any created system, such as government or the church. The fact that he considered these institutions man-made was heresy in itself. Individual rights and free will were given to man, according to Milton, by the Creator. This pursuit of individual rights created many confrontations with the powerful men of his time.

On June 14, 1643, Parliament passed the Ordinance for Printing. The Tudor monarchs and the early Stuarts had attempted such controls, but Parliament was the true source of power in the 17th century. The Parliament wanted to guarantee the preservation of order and uniformity in the church and state. Milton realized that the real goal was to limit what the public read. In November of 1644 he published Aeropagitica, a defense of the free press. Milton wrote that censorship was an attribute of "degenerate" cultures. In Aeropagitica, Milton stated:

When God gave him reason, he gave him freedom to choose, for reason is but choosing...

Milton's distaste for the monarchy led directly to his embracing the rule of Oliver Cromwell. From 1630 through 1658 Milton wrote at least 24 sonnets. Many of these celebrate the rise of "Lord General Cromwell" and "New Forcers of Conscience." When Cromwell's government collapsed and Charles II ascended the thrown, Milton was imprisoned, fined, and his property confiscated. Yet Milton steadfastly accepted his decisions and the consequences.

Three years after the fall of Cromwell's government, Milton began writing Paradise Lost. Readers of the epic often find Satan the most compelling character, especially at the beginning of the poem, which he dominates. Satan has used his free will to choose his role in the universe. The famous statement by Satan that it is "better to reign in Hell than serve in Heaven" is an endorsement of individual rights and responsibility, versus serving authority. Satan describes his enemy as "the tyranny of Heaven." Nietzsche would appreciate the honest ambition of Satan.

In Paradise Lost, Adam is heroic only because he accepts his fate. He does not fight Satan, argue at length with the Creator, or run away from responsibility. Adam admits to and embraces his guilt in order to tolerate his mortality. This is the same acceptance we later read about in Camus' The Stranger; the sinner admits to his deeds and eventually embraces fate.

Chronology

1608 Born in Bread Street, Cheapside
1629 Graduates from Christ's College, Cambridge with an A.B. (bachelor's degree)
1632 Receives A.M. (master's degree) from Christ's College
1634 Writes Comus for a nobel family in Shropshire
1637 Contributes Lycidas to a volume honoring a Cambridge classmate.
1642 May or June Marries Mary Powell, daughter of a royalist squire. She leaves within weeks.
1643 to 1645 Publishes several essays in support of divorce.
1644 Writes the essay On Education, debating the writings of German scholar Samuel Hartlib.
1644 November 24 Publishes the essay Areopagitica, defending the right to a "free press" in opposition to regulations approved by Parliament.
1645 Mary returns to Milton. She gives birth to three daughters in the following years.
1649 Publishes a series of essays in support of Cromwell and defending the execution of Charles I.
1649 Goes blind, but is still appointed Latin Secretary to Cromwell's Council of State.
1652 Wife Mary dies.
1656 Marries Katherine Woodcock.
1658 Katherine dies during childbirth.
1660 Charles II returns to the throne. Milton is imprisoned briefly for treason and his property is confiscated.
1663 Marries Elizabeth Minshull.
1663 Begins writing Paradise Lost.
1667 Publishes Paradise Lost.
1671 Publishes Paradise Regained, a tribute to Christ.
1674 Publishes the play Samson Agonistes.
1674 Dies of gout.

Works

  • Comus, Masque: 1634
  • Lycidas, Poem: 1637
  • Paradise Lost, Poem: 1667
  • Paradise Regained, Poem: 1671
  • Samson Agonistes, Play: 1671

Quotes

The mind is its own place, and in itself
Can make a Heaven of Hell, a Hell of Heaven.
-- Paradise Lost, Book 1, line 254. Satan speaking of his new domain.

To reign is worth ambition, though in Hell:
Better to reign in Hell than serve in Heaven.
-- Paradise Lost, Book 1, line 262. Satan speaking of his new domain.

Blaise Pascal

Blaise Pascal is best known as a mathematician and scientist, but he dedicated the later half of his life to religious study and philosophy. As a mathematician, Pascal is credited with the modern theory of probability, the properties of the cycloid, and advancements in differential calculus. His experiments with fluids and their tendencies toward equilibrium led to the hydraulic press.

It is possible to make a comparison between Pascal and Edmund Husserl. Both men were dedicated to mathematics and formal logic. However, their logical studies led to philosophical questions about the nature of existence. As a young man Pascal came under Jansenist influence. At the age of 30 or 31, Pascal experienced a religious awakening. In 1654 he entered the convent/monastery at Port-Royal, devoting his attention primarily to religious writing. His works include Provincial Letters, a defense of the Jansenists; and the Pensées, which preach the necessity of mystic faith in understanding the universe.

Pascal's philosophy is a also forerunner of Kierkegaard's. Pascal concluded that faith is not logical, in much the same way that Kierkegaard concluded that religion was a "leap of faith" requiring pure devotion. For Pascal, this philosophy was the result of a lifetime dedicated to science that could not explain his own religious faith.

The most famous of Pascal's attempts to explain his religious commitment was Pascal's Razor. Paraphrased, Pascal stated that it made more sense to believe in God, in case He existed, than to deny the existence of God and risk the consequences. The difficulty in this argument is that it makes it possible to argue that one should believe in all religions, as that would lower the potential risks of an afterlife considerably.

Chronology

1623 Born
1642 Invents a simple adding machine to assist his father, a tax collector.
1654 Enters the convent/monastery at Port-Royal and dedicates his life to religious meditations and writings.
1662 Dies.
1670 Pensées published posthumously.

Works

  • Provincial Letters, Essays: 1656
  • Pensées, Aphorisms: 1670

Quotes

We run heedlessly into the abyss after putting something in front of us to stop us seeing it. Pensées

Man finds nothing so intolerable as to be in a state of complete rest, without passions, without occupation, without diversion, without effort. Then he feels his nullity, loneliness, inadequacy, dependence, helplessness, emptiness. Pensées

Man is only a reed, the weakest in nature; but he is a thinking reed. There is no need for the whole universe to take up arms to crush him: a vapor, a drop of water is enough to kill him. But even if the universe were to crush him, man would still be nobler than his slayer, because he knows that he is dying and the advantage the universe has over him. The universe knows nothing of this. Pensées

It is the heart which perceives God and not the reason. That is what faith is: God perceived by the heart, not by the reason. Pensées

Men never do evil so fully and cheerfully as when we do it out of conscience. Pensées


Philosophy Mailing List I established a loosely moderated mailing list in 1996. The community is very active and its members tend to know much more than I do. Collectively we are a better resource than an individual.

Subscribe to "ExistList"
Powered by groups.yahoo.com
Read the Exist List FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions)

Google
Web Tameri/Existential Primer
Forums | About CSW | Webmaster | ©2005 C. S. Wyatt; 03-Sep-2007